Baybolt vs Mitchell 1
An honest, side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, and value to help you choose the best auto repair shop software for your business.
$79
Baybolt / month
~$114 (Manager SE only)
Mitchell 1 / month
14
Baybolt Advantages
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
See exactly what you get with each platform. No hidden fees, no surprises.
| Feature | Baybolt $79/mo | Mitchell 1 ~$114/mo (Manager SE only) |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $79/mo | ~$114/mo (management only) |
| Unlimited Mechanics | +$15/user/mo | |
| Digital Vehicle Inspections | +$139/mo add-on | |
| VIN Scanner & Decoder | VIN decode | |
| Parts Search (Multi-Source) | eBay, Amazon, RockAuto | Integrated suppliers |
| Invoice & Estimate Generator | ||
| Mechanic Scheduling | Basic | |
| Time Clock (Mobile) | ||
| Kanban Project Board | ||
| Customer Progress Tracker | ||
| Two-Way Texting | +$39/mo add-on | |
| Real-Time Notifications | Limited | |
| CSV Data Export | ||
| Built-in Appointment Booking | Basic | |
| Google SSO Sign-In | ||
| PWA Mobile App | ||
| 14-Day Free Trial | Demo only |
Where Baybolt Wins
Key advantages that make Baybolt the smarter choice for independent auto repair shops.
Modern, cloud-native interface vs legacy desktop-era design
DVIs, texting, and all features included in one $79/mo plan
No need to bundle separate products or pay for add-ons
Mobile-first design with VIN scanner and clock-in from any phone
Where Mitchell 1 Falls Short
Common pain points reported by Mitchell 1 users.
Outdated user interface compared to modern cloud software
DVI (ProSpect) costs an additional ~$139/month
Two-way texting (MessageCenter) costs an extra ~$39/month
Requires bundling multiple products to get full functionality
Quote-based pricing makes cost comparison difficult
What Mitchell 1 Does Well
We believe in honest comparisons. Here is where Mitchell 1 has strengths.
Extensive OEM repair information database (ProDemand)
SureTrack real-world confirmed fixes from technicians
Over 180 business reports available
Long-standing industry reputation since 1918
See the Difference for Yourself
Try Baybolt free for 14 days. No credit card needed. All features included.
Start Free Trial$79/mo after trial • Unlimited mechanics • Cancel anytime